Categories
Uncategorized

To Judge or Not To Judge? Yes and No.

“Why do you pass judgement on your brother?”1—Paul, to the church in Rome

“I blame [ insert name here ]!”

How many times have we heard someone with finger figuratively pointed pronounce accusation thusly? How often have we done so ourselves? Each time, it gives me pause to ask “Why?”—not as in “Why is this the person I blame?” but as in “Why are our hearts so bent on accusation?” In this “Don’t judge” generation, we’re actually pretty adept at it, aren’t we?

Truth must be discerned and justice met, of course, and individuals must be accountable in relationships and to society as a whole. What I’m speaking about, however, is the heart that is eager to declare the guilt of another, quick to blame others and quicker still to defend itself. How can we who have received grace be so reluctant at times to extend it to others? Jesus warned the crowd gathered on the hillside to hear him: “Judge not, that you be not judged. For with the judgment you pronounce you will be judged, and with the measure you use it will be measured to you.”2 Paul likewise writes, “You have no excuse, O man, every one of you who judges. For in passing judgment on another you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, practice the very same things.”3 Simply stated: Judge at your own peril. Seriously. They’re not kidding.

But didn’t Paul actually exhort us to judge? Yes, in a sense he did. To Corinthian believers, he wrote, “The spiritual person judges all things . . .”4 But the Greek word translated “judge” (anakrino) in this verse does not mean to condemn another (krino), but to examine a matter—to search it out, discerning and weighing the facts that lead to an evaluation. We are to do this not in a spirit of condemnation, but in pursuit of truth and from a heart of grace, that we would all walk united in the ways that are good and right. Paul concludes, “We have the mind of Christ.”5 Then as people in Christ, indwelled by the Spirit of truth, we must discern right from wrong, not vindictively, but as people who, “from [Jesus’] fullness . . . have all received, grace upon grace.”6

We do well, then, to recall our own moments of grace (for there are many)—the angst we felt beforehand, the relief we felt as undeserving recipients, and the humility and gratitude we recall even now. Then in this spirit of liberty, may our hearts not be set on blame and condemnation of others, but on truth and grace, intercession and restoration. May we joyfully extend what we have gladly received.

Father, from a heart of compassion, you have forgiven us much. Fill us with your Spirit that, in whatever form it might take, we too will seek the best for those we might have otherwise accused. In Christ we pray. Amen.

1 Romans 14:10 ESV)
2 Matthew 7:1-2 ESV
3 Romans 2:1 ESV
4 1 Corinthians 2:15 ESV
5 1 Corinthians 2:16 ESV
6 John 1:16 ESV

Leave a Reply